# What Do Companies A/B Test In Paywall Secondary Actions Like Restore And Skip?

Source: Lazyweb Research
Author: Ali Abouelatta, Lazyweb Research
Published: 2026-07-07
Updated: July 2026
Sample size: n=112
Category: [What companies A/B test, by page area](https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/category/what-companies-a-b-test-by-page-area)
Tags: paywall, mobile, monetization, ux-patterns, experiments, cancellation
HTML: https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/what-companies-ab-test-secondary-actions-paywalls
Markdown: https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/what-companies-ab-test-secondary-actions-paywalls.md

**Answer.** Across 112 secondary-action experiments tracked by Lazyweb Research (out of 2,160 area-annotated experiments), the pattern is subtraction: removing opt-ins, ads, and escape hatches that pull attention off the yes/no decision [1]. Secondary actions are the seventh most-tested area (5.3%) but low-impact by model score (avg 2.90/5, only 9.8% scored high-impact) [1][2]. The area skews mobile (79 of 112 annotations) because it maps to paywall furniture like restore-purchases links and trial-reminder rows [1].

> Secondary-action edits make up 112 of 2,160 annotated experiments (5.3%), 71% of them mobile, with an average model-assigned impact of 2.90/5, per Lazyweb Research, July 2026.

## The finding: remove the distractions around the button

SECONDARY ACTIONS covers restore-purchases links, skip links, opt-ins, and other escape hatches around a primary CTA [1]. It is tested in 112 annotations across 107 experiments, 79 of them mobile and 33 web [1]. Average model-assigned impact is 2.90/5 and only 9.8% (11 of 112) scored high-impact, so these are refinements, not swings [1][2]. The observed direction is consistently subtractive: strip elements that compete with the decision [3].

## What the observed edits look like

Two representative mobile examples: removing an 'Email me before my trial ends' opt-in row beneath the pricing text, and removing a third-party banner ad at the bottom of a paywall and replacing it with a 'Restore purchases' link [3].

| Move | Platform | What it removes | Rationale (inferred) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Drop trial-reminder opt-in | mobile | last-moment anxiety cue | keep focus on one yes/no |
| Swap banner ad for restore link | mobile | attention leak + distrust | cleaner purchase moment, still serves subscribers |

Both keep a single primary decision in view [3].

## How to apply it

Audit your paywall for anything below or beside the CTA that isn't the decision: reminder opt-ins, third-party ads, secondary links. The observed pattern is that removing them keeps attention on the purchase [3]. Keep genuinely required affordances (restore purchases is a store requirement and shows up as the replacement, not the casualty) [3]. Because model impact here is low, treat these as polish once the offer and pricing are settled [1].

## Caveats

Impact is a model-assigned 1-5 score on observed before/after diffs, not measured lift [4]. The 33 web annotations are absolute counts only per Lazyweb Research's web-thinness rule [4]. Named examples are single observed diffs with inferred rationale, not proof that removal wins [4].

## The numbers

| Stat | Computed from |
| --- | --- |
| 112 SECONDARY ACTIONS annotations (5.3% of 2,160), avg impact 2.90/5, avg confidence 3.47, 107 experiments; 79 mobile / 33 web | area_SECONDARY_ACTIONS |
| SECONDARY ACTIONS high-impact (4+/5) share 9.8% (11 of 112) | high_impact_share_by_area |
| Observed moves: Zero removed 'Email me before my trial ends' opt-in; WeatherRadar replaced a banner ad with a 'Restore purchases' link | qualitative SECONDARY ACTIONS zero, weatherradar |
| 71% of secondary-action annotations are mobile (79 of 112); impact is a model-assigned 1-5 score | area_SECONDARY_ACTIONS; universe |

## Methodology

Universe is 112 SECONDARY ACTIONS annotations within 2,160 area-level annotations over 1,126 detected experiments in the ~800 tracked-apps corpus. Areas and rationale are LLM-inferred from observed before/after screenshots; impact is a model-assigned 1-5 score, July 2026, for relative ranking only.

## Visual references

Real, in-market app screens tracked by Lazyweb Research:

- Chatgpt: https://zlfyzdmohcskkucuunmk.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/screenshots/prod11_chatgpt/lazyscreenshots/2024_07_14_16-38-19_89342939.png
- Citizen: https://zlfyzdmohcskkucuunmk.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/screenshots/news7_citizen/lazyscreenshots/2023_04_17_19-00-25_2CD826B5.png
- Alltrails: https://zlfyzdmohcskkucuunmk.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/screenshots/health11_alltrails/lazyscreenshots/2024_11_23_13-53-12_753AC24C.png
- Gauthmath: https://zlfyzdmohcskkucuunmk.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/screenshots/edu13_gauthmath/backlog/2025_11_17_18-33-19_9527E2CE.png

## Sources & citations

- [1] Lazyweb Research analysis of 112 secondary-action experiments (~800 tracked apps), July 2026. SECONDARY ACTIONS annotations within 2,160 area-level annotations over 1,126 detected experiments.
- [2] Lazyweb Research analysis of high-impact-share by area (n>=30 areas), July 2026. Share scored impact 4+/5 by the model; relative ranking only.
- [3] Lazyweb Research analysis of 2,160 annotated UI experiments (~800 tracked apps), July 2026. Named examples are individual observed diffs with LLM-inferred rationale.
- [4] Lazyweb Research analysis of 4,814 detected experiments (~800 tracked apps), July 2026. Web cuts are absolute counts only; impact/confidence are model-assigned 1-5 scores.

## Related questions

- [What Are Companies A/B Testing In Landing-Page Navigation Right Now?](https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/what-companies-ab-test-nav-landing-pages)
- [Which Page Areas Look Highest-Impact In Detected A/B Tests?](https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/which-page-areas-highest-impact-experiments)
- [How Often Do Companies Actually Change The Paywall CTA Text When They Test It?](https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/how-often-paywall-cta-text-changes-experiments)
- [Which Page Areas Get A/B Tested Most — Hero, Pricing, or CTA?](https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/which-page-areas-get-ab-tested-most)
- [Which Experiment Areas Look Highest-Impact in Detected A/B Tests?](https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/which-page-areas-look-highest-impact-in-detected-tests)
- [What Are Companies A/B Testing on Their Hero Sections Right Now?](https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/what-are-companies-ab-testing-on-hero-sections)
- [What Are Companies A/B Testing on the Offer (Discounts and Trials)?](https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/what-are-companies-ab-testing-on-the-offer)
- [What Are Companies A/B Testing on Pricing Right Now?](https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/what-are-companies-ab-testing-on-pricing)

## Explore the evidence

- [Billing toggle experiment kit](https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/billing-toggle-experiment-kit?utm_source=lazyweb&utm_medium=research&utm_campaign=billing-toggle-kit)
- [Cal AI annual-plan and trial presentation](https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/cal-ai-paywall-annual-plan-and-trial)
- [Monthly versus annual billing toggles](https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/monthly-vs-annual-billing-toggle-pricing)
- [Billing cadence versus plan tiers](https://design.lazyweb.com/blog/annual-billing-toggle-vs-plan-tiers)
- [Cal AI trial-introduction screens](https://design.lazyweb.com/flow/cal-ai/onboarding-paywall)

## Continue your research

[Connect Lazyweb to your coding agent](https://www.lazyweb.com/mcp-install)